Most conversations about AI in small business start with what the tools can do. Earn the Change starts somewhere else: with who decides.

That question gives three modes, and they work best as rungs on a ladder.

The three rungs

  • Assist. A person asks, the AI drafts, the person decides. Assistants and copilots live here. The AI helps, but a human makes every call.
  • Embedded. The AI handles one defined step inside a workflow. People handle the exceptions.
  • Agentic. The AI carries several steps on its own, with people at checkpoints chosen in advance.

Each rung up hands the AI more responsibility. So each rung up has to be earned.

Exhibit 1

Who decides moves from the person, to the workflow, to the AI

Highlighted boxes mark where a person makes the call.

Assist

Decides: the person

Person asks

a question, or for a draft

AI drafts or suggests

nothing goes out yet

Person decides

edits, sends, or throws it out

Needs: the normal path

a one-page SOP is enough

Embedded

Decides: the workflow

Work arrives

an invoice, an email, a form

AI runs one defined step

sorts, tags, or summarizes

Inside the rules?

yes flows on · no, a person decides

Needs: exceptions written

what doesn't fit, where it goes

Agentic

Decides: the AI, within limits

Goal, inside set limits

what it may do on its own

AI plans and acts

several steps, using tools

Person signs off

at checkpoints chosen first

Delivers, can be undone

start with reversible actions

Needs: decision rights

do, ask first, never touch

The more the AI does on its own, the more the process underneath has to be proven.

Source: Earn the Change, Troy Green

Climb one rung at a time

The same belief that runs through the whole book applies here: prove it at a lower level of autonomy before you let it act on its own.

Start at Assist. Run it as a small test, on real work, with your three numbers. Only when that holds do you consider moving one step up. Skipping straight to Agentic because the demo was impressive is one of the most common, and most expensive, mistakes.

And plenty of processes should stay at Assist forever. That's a perfectly good answer.

Exhibit 2

Autonomy is earned one level at a time

Prove each level before climbing. If the protect number slips, step down.

Agentic

Protect: Real consequences

AI acts, people at checkpoints

↑ proven: move up↓ slips? step down

Embedded

Protect: Its error rate

AI runs one defined step

↑ proven: move up↓ slips? step down

Assist

Protect: Time spent checking

Person decides, every time

Source: Earn the Change, Troy Green

You can only safely automate livestock

Embedded and agentic AI need a process that's standard, stable, and written down, including its exceptions. A one-page description of the normal path is enough for a person, and enough for Assist, because a person still decides. It isn't enough when the AI acts alone. For that, you also need to write down what doesn't fit, where it goes, and who decides.

Who decides, and who owns the mistakes

At every rung, someone has to own the AI's mistakes. Not the vendor. A named person on your team, whose role has changed to match. If nobody can say who that is, you're not ready to move up.

You also need a step-down rule: what result tells you to move the AI back down a rung, and who is allowed to switch it off.

Exhibit 3

If authority moved but accountability didn't, expect overrides

Before AI

Who decides

The person

Who answers for it

The person

Blame matches authority

AI added, blame stayed

Who decides

The AI

Who answers for it

Still the person

Expect overrides

Blame moved too

Who decides

The AI, by set rules

Who answers for it

Owner of the rules

People let it work

Source: Earn the Change, Troy Green

Watch the hidden cost of checking

At Assist, the most important protect number is the time people spend checking and fixing what the AI produces. A tool that saves ten hours a week and quietly costs eight hours of checking hasn't saved ten hours.

There's a simple way to find out. Sit with one person while they finish one real task with the tool. Make a tally mark every time they correct or redo its work. If fixing takes longer than doing it by hand, stop there. The step with the most marks is usually your next obstacle.

Exhibit 4

One process, three levels of autonomy, each one earned

An HVAC company's after-hours calls, 4 p.m. to 8 a.m., split by what's at stake.

After-hours call

4 p.m. to 8 a.m.

Seasonal tune-ups · Agentic

AI answers and books open slots; every booking can be undone

Repairs · Embedded

AI sorts urgent or routine; routine calls go to the morning queue

Emergencies · always a person

Urgent calls page the on-call technician

Source: Earn the Change, Troy Green

Ask the vendor the right question

A demo is built to impress, on clean data, in a controlled setting. So ask any vendor to run their tool on your own messy cases. Ask where your data goes, who can see it, and whether it's used to train anything else. If you can't get clear answers, treat that as a no.

Before you buy

Pick one place your business uses AI today, or is thinking about it. Write down which rung it's on, who decides, and who owns its mistakes. If any of those are blank, that's your first step. Not a new tool.